Home View Cart Bookmark This Page Contact Us
 
Categories
Apple iPods
Bed & Bath
Books
Camera and Photo
DIY & Tools
DVD
Home & Garden
MP3 & Digital Audio
Music
Office & Computing
PC & Video Games
Personal Care
Photography
Software
Toys
Video
Search Keywords
pet shop boys
the agricultural notebook
poultry
chicken houses
voucher
courgette
multiple sclerosis
brian reeder
digital cameras
chicken arks
Home > Book > Doctor Who: the Celestial Toymaker (Doctor Who)
Doctor Who: the Celestial Toymaker (Doctor Who)

List Price : £13.99
Our Price : £9.99
     
3 Used :from £6.99
6 New :from £7.97
   
Availability : Usually dispatched within 24 hours
Add Review
Custom Reviews: 
again! again!
2 out of 5 stars.
As usual the BBC give us a superbly presented soundtrack. The quality of the product and the linking narration is superb.

The problem with the celestial toymaker lies with the story. It's a great concept - the tardis crew caught by a mysterious, fantastical being and forced to play his games - and without the episodes you can conjure up your own visuals in your mind which are possibly better than the tv ones were. There's an interesting hint that the toymaker and the doctor have met before, and that they're very powerful beings above the concerns of petty mortals.

But the story is repetitive. The first three episodes are pretty much the same plot over and over again. And that gets dull.

Things pick up a little in part four with the appearance of cyril the schoolboy, who is quite a menacing villain thanks to great work from the actor, and the ending of the tale is very nicely done. But one good episode doesn't quite make up for three tedious ones

A badly executed concept
1 out of 5 stars.
I was aware that "The Celestial Toymaker", originally by Brian Hayles but extensively rewritten by two of the show's producers, had come to have a poor reputation in fandom before I listened to it. However, I am capable of finding redeeming qualities in almost any "Doctor Who" story.
This one is something of an exception. However one looks at it (it's at least imaginative), there's no escaping the fact that "The Celestial Toymaker" is deathly dull and hard to sit through (even though episode four survives in full and can be watched on the DVD set "Lost in Time"). It's not the actors' fault, it's simply a very bad story.
Steven and Dodo spend four episodes playing games with very little sense of danger or tension despite the apparent threats they face. The Doctor, meanwhile, is made invisible and mute so that William Hartnell could go on holiday for two weeks, resulting in scenes where the Toymaker (a respectable performance by actor Michael Gough) basically talks to himself. Steven shouts and Dodo displays a totally blinkered stupidity against the threats the two companions are supposedly facing by repeatedly empathising with the Toymakers' intermittently homicidal creations.
Once can see what the producers were trying to achieve, but the extensive rewriting creates in "The Celestial Toymaker" a tedious and lamentable four episodes of "Doctor Who". Recommended for total completists - such as myself - only.


Cheap and cheerful
5 out of 5 stars.
I'm 13 years old and I hate the new Doctor Who series. Why not sit back and enjoy some light hearted and cheerful Doctor Who instead of the noisy, fast paced and modern rubbish? This story, The Celestial Toymaker, is a perfect example of the quiet and entertaining series that ignorant people don't understand. Don't let a few CSO effects and wobbly sets put you off a classic show that has been turned into a mess over 2006.

A holiday for the Doctor ...
5 out of 5 stars.
The odd thing about Dr Who in the Sixties was that Bill Hartnell was forever going away on a fortnight's holiday! I've lost track of how many Dr Who releases the BBC have now done of Hartnell stories in which Peter Purves is left to carry the show single handed.

He has to do so in 'The Massacre', where Hartnell can't appear as both the Abbott and the Doctor; he has to do so in 'The Daleks Masterplan' when Hartnell is again absent; and also in 'The Time Meddler' - at a point at which he's only been in the Dr Who series for a mere 3 weeks!

If they could have squeezed the poor guy into 'Mission to the Unknown' (in which not only Hartnell but ALL of the regular cast was missing!) I'm sure they would have.

Happily, Peter Purves has real style and a ready wit, and never seems phased by what must have been rather a daunting prospect. Here, the Celestial Toymaker waves his hand and the Doctor becomes invisible for a couple of episodes (a pretty neat trick on an audio recording!), and is represented in the middle two episodes of this serial only by some occasional pre-recorded dialogue, leaving Steven and Dodo to give the Toymaker the runaround for a fortnight.

It's an enjoyable romp, enlivened too by the presence of Carmen Silvera (from the tv series 'Allo 'Allo) and that fine old character actor Campbell Singer, as our heroes' opponents in a series of deadly games, loosely based on children's nursery rhymes. And of course, to the youngsters in the audience in the 1960's, this gave the serial a particular edge - being menaced by their toys, which come to life and then try to kill Steven and Dodo.

On the surface, to us now as adults, the story is just a charming fantasy. But with playing cards, nursery rhyme characters and Billy Bunter all coming to life at the drop of a hat, and turning out to be lethal, it somehow didn't seem quite so harmless at the time...

A classic?!
1 out of 5 stars.
I cannot understand why this story has so long been hailed as a classic. Bill Hartnell is on holiday for two episodes, the games become annoying and the whole mess just drags on and on.




Powered by Amazon Shop Copyright © 2005 GhostScripter