"The Moonbase", by Kit Pedlar, is one of those shaky 1960s stories that is enjoyable in its quaint own way without being particularly dramatic or exciting. It represents a classic example of the "base under siege" format that would typify the later Troughton years and benefits by being produced before the format became too formulaic. The Cybermen have had a makeover since their first appearance in The Tenth Planet and now appear much more impassive and menacing, complete with their new electronic, monotone voices. The supporting characters avoid being completely generic by the introduction of a convincing Frenchman named Benoit (André Maranne) and one of those gruff, pragmatic salt-of-the Earth types in Captain Hobson (Patrick Barr). The rest of the supporting players blend into one another, but all do a decent job. The episodes that survive in video, meanwhile, display imaginative production design given the budget available, and the model work is more convincing than some. The lunar surface is quite well-conveyed, too; it's not obvious where the set ends and the static backdrop begins. The sight of an army of Cybermen striding across the barren landscape is quite an iconic image, and I was glad to have the opportunity to see the final part of the story on the screen (they are available on the DVD set "Lost in Time"). On the audio recording, clear narration is provided by Frazer Hines. With fair sound design and familiar music cues, "The Moonbase" is an unremarkable but solid entry into 1960s Doctor Who canon.
|
| The Moonbase features the return of the Cybermen, and following this story, they had firmly established themselves as 'second favourite monsters' with the fans (the Daleks being first of course!) A story from the 'cross-over season' when Hartnell relinquished the role, sees Troughton firmly settled into his new role, unlike previous stories - i.e. Power of the Daleks and The Highlanders, this story establishes Troughton's character as was continued for the remainder of the actors' time with the show. Whilst some have argued that the Moonbase is merely a re-write of the Tenth Planet several months earlier, I would urge listeners to ignore that, true the story is about a base under-seige (but most Doctor Who stories at that time used similar plots!) but the characters and the content of the story are different. Presumably most fans will have seen the two surviving episodes, however, listening to the complete audio soundtrack, allows the storyline to develop comfortably across the four episodes whilst hiding disasterous holes that were apparent on the visual material i.e. The Cyberman hiding like a Scooby-Doo villian at the end of an episode!! The cast themselves come across well on audio, Troughton, as ever, having settled into the role, is excellent and the supporting cast are reasonable. However, the only nag might be that the introduction of Fraser Hines as Jamie has limited the dialogue of Craze and Willkes, and some of the base personnel are hardly represented. Obviously the return of the Cybermen is a welcome for fans, and this story, being their second outing, is still fresh and effective. Being written by their original creator, Peddler, the story is well thought out. Furthermore, the new Cybermen voices give them a greater sense of power, unlike the 'sing-song' voices of The Tenth Planet. Overall, the story comes across well on audio, the background music is chilling and helps to give the story suspsense on the audio medium. The narration is good, although at times it is lacking in places, and the Cybervoices are difficult to distinguish at times. Not a bad place to start for Troughton adventures, and the price is fairly reasonable.
|
| An encampment of humanity facing a threat from outside- mysterious events: People going missing, deaths, strange radio interferences but above all the Doctor and his companions are singled out as the instigators of these horrors. The Moonbase- a true Doctor Who classic from the golden age of the Patrick Troughton era and what better way for the series to enforce its science fictional elements then have the story set on the moon. Here you get a tense, mystery filled space chiller featuring the return of some very effective villains: The Cybermen! Their reasons and motives for their actions are just as chilling as their monotonous metallic voices. They are relentless in their mission to invade and take control of the moonbase.
Here you can see how truly effective these silver giants are when told about revenge and other human concepts. 'We know of this weakness of yours, we are fortunate. We do not possess feelings!' So if you there's nothing on the box in the evening, plug in your CD player and slip on the headphones and stare up at the night sky and the moon high above. Then picture the Doctor and his friends as they battle against the evil menace of the Cybermen...
|